Looking Beyond the EcoNook 24 inch Portable Propane? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The EcoNook 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit with Grill is a substantial unit at 24 inches wide and 32 pounds. It combines a propane heat source with a cooking grate and lava rocks. This setup works well if you need a larger surface for grilling and warming guests simultaneously. However, its weight and size may not suit every outdoor space. Some buyers prioritize lighter portability or smaller footprints for decks and RVs. Others might prefer wood burning for a different ambiance or higher BTU output for faster heating.
We selected these econook 24 inch portable propane alternatives because their specifications overlap with your needs. The list includes lighter propane models like the Ciays 21-Inch and Amazon Basics 19-inch options for easier transport. It also features wood-burning choices like the BALI Outdoors 22-Inch for those who do not require propane connectivity. Each product in this guide is chosen based on published specs such as weight, dimensions, and fuel type. This approach helps you find a unit that fits your specific patio or camping requirements without guessing.
How these alternatives compare to EcoNook
Ciays 21-Inch Propane Fire Pit with Grill Grate
The Ciays 21-Inch Propane Fire Pit with Grill Grate is smaller than the EcoNook at 20.7 inches wide. It weighs 23.9 pounds, making it nearly 8 pounds lighter and easier to move around your patio. You get 58,000 BTU of heat output, which is slightly less than some larger units but sufficient for personal warmth. It includes a cooking grate, similar to the EcoNook, but the smaller footprint means less surface area for grilling. This model suits buyers who want portability without sacrificing cooking capability. If you find the EcoNook too heavy or large for your space, the Ciays offers a more manageable size while still providing propane convenience and a grill for simple meals.
Amazon Basics 19-inch Propane Fire Pit
The Amazon Basics 19-inch Propane Fire Pit is significantly more compact than the EcoNook. It measures 18.5 inches wide and weighs only 19.8 pounds, making it the lightest propane option on this list. It delivers 55,000 BTU of heat, which is lower than the EcoNook’s implied higher output due to its larger burner system. This unit lacks a cooking grate, so it focuses purely on warmth and ambiance. It is ideal for small patios or decks where space is limited. If you do not need to grill and prioritize easy transport and a lower profile, this model is a practical choice. It provides reliable propane heat in a package that is much easier to store and carry than the 32-pound EcoNook.
BALI Outdoors 22-Inch Smokeless Fire Pit with Grill
The BALI Outdoors 22-Inch Smokeless Fire Pit with Grill uses wood burning instead of propane. It is 22 inches wide, slightly smaller than the EcoNook, and weighs 24.8 pounds. It features a smokeless design that reduces ash and smoke compared to traditional wood fires. Like the EcoNook, it includes a cooking grate for preparing food over the flames. However, you must source and manage wood fuel rather than connecting to a propane tank. This model is best for those who prefer the aroma and look of a real wood fire but want a cleaner burn. If you are in an area where wood fires are permitted and you want a smokeless experience with grilling capability, this is a strong alternative to the propane-dependent EcoNook.
Florise 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit with 2 Grills
The Florise 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit with 2 Grills is much larger than the EcoNook. It measures 36 inches wide and weighs 27.1 pounds. It features two cooking grates, offering double the grilling surface of the EcoNook’s single grate. It burns wood, requiring you to manage logs and ash rather than propane tanks. This unit is designed for large backyard gatherings where maximum cooking capacity and substantial warmth are priorities. It is not portable in the same way as the propane models due to its size and wood fuel requirements. If you need extensive grilling space for a large group and do not mind using wood, this model provides superior cooking utility and a more significant heat presence than the EcoNook.
Outland Living 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit
The Outland Living 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit is a compact alternative to the EcoNook. It measures 19 inches wide and weighs 22 pounds, making it lighter and smaller. It delivers 58,000 BTU of heat and features a smokeless design. This model is marketed for use on decks, camping trips, and RVs, emphasizing its suitability for small or restricted spaces. It does not include a cooking grate, focusing solely on heat and ambiance. If you prioritize portability and smokeless operation for travel or small decks, this is a better fit than the bulkier EcoNook. It offers reliable propane heat in a package that is easier to transport and store, though you sacrifice the ability to grill directly over the fire.
Gasfargo 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit
The Gasfargo 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit offers 60,000 BTU of heat output, which is higher than most competitors. It measures 19 inches wide and weighs 22 pounds, similar in footprint to the Outland Living model but with more power. It includes a cooking grate and a protective cover, adding convenience for storage and outdoor use. This model is designed for portable cooking and high heat in small groups. It is smaller and lighter than the EcoNook, making it easier to move. If you want maximum heat output and cooking capability in a compact, portable package, the Gasfargo is a strong choice. It trades the larger size and lava rock aesthetic of the EcoNook for higher BTU efficiency and added accessories like a cover.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
EcoNook 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit with Grill
Best for: patio gatherings requiring cooking space
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Diameter or Width
- 24 inches
- Material
- Steel, stainless steel
- Included Accessories
- Lid, grill, hose, regulator, lava rocks
- Design
- Smokeless
- Features
- Cooking Grate
View on Amazon: EcoNook 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit with Grill Affiliate link
The EcoNook 24 inch portable propane fire pit offers a 24-inch diameter steel bowl with a stainless steel burner. It includes a cooking grate for BBQ, a mesh screen, and lava rocks. The unit weighs 32 pounds and features foldable legs for storage. It connects to a standard 32-lb propane tank via an 8.5-ft hose. This setup suits those wanting a smokeless campfire alternative with grilling capabilities.
Pros
- 24-inch diameter provides ample heat and space
- Includes a stainless steel cooking grate for BBQ
- Foldable legs allow for compact storage
- Comes with a mesh screen and lava rocks
Cons
- 32-pound weight is heavier than 21-inch competitors
- No remote control for flame adjustment
- Propane tank is not included
Good fit if
- You want a fire pit that doubles as a grill
- You need a 24-inch diameter for larger gatherings
- You prefer a smokeless propane option for patios
Skip if
- You need a lightweight unit under 25 pounds
- You require a built-in propane tank
- You want a square fire pit shape
Verdict: EcoNook 24 Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit fits buyers who prioritize a larger cooking surface and durable steel construction over lightweight portability. It is ideal for patio users who want to grill and warm guests simultaneously.
Ciays 21-Inch Propane Fire Pit with Grill Grate
Best for: portable heating and cooking on patios
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Heat Output
- 58,000 BTU
- Diameter or Width
- 20.7 inches
- Material
- Metal
- Ignition Type
- Piezo Electric Ignition
- Included Accessories
- Grate, 10 ft hose, lava rock, lid
View on Amazon: Ciays 21-Inch Propane Fire Pit with Grill Grate Affiliate link
The Ciays 21-inch propane fire pit delivers 58,000 BTU of smoke-free warmth in a compact, round design. It features a cast iron cooking grate and piezo electric ignition that requires no batteries. Foldable legs and a carrying strap make it easy to transport and store. This unit includes a lid, lava rock, and a 10-foot gas hose, offering a complete setup for patios or campsites.
Pros
- 58,000 BTU heat output for effective warmth
- Piezo electric ignition eliminates need for batteries
- Foldable legs allow compact storage at 8 inches tall
- Cast iron grate provides durable cooking surface
Cons
- 21-inch diameter is smaller than the 24-inch EcoNook
- Manual ignition requires holding the knob for several seconds
- No remote control or electronic display for operation
Good fit if
- You need a portable unit with foldable legs for easy transport
- You want a cooking grate for grilling alongside heating
- You prefer battery-free ignition reliability
Skip if
- You require a larger 24-inch or bigger fire bowl
- You want electronic push-button ignition without manual holding
- You need a square or rectangular shape design
Verdict: Ciays 21-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit offers reliable heat and cooking utility in a portable package, making it a solid choice for those prioritizing transportability and manual control over larger dimensions.
Amazon Basics 19-inch Propane Fire Pit
Best for: small patios needing portable propane warmth
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Heat Output
- 55,000 BTU
- Diameter or Width
- 19 inches
- Material
- Steel
- Included Accessories
- Carry strap, lid, lava rock, gas hose
- Color
- Black
View on Amazon: Amazon Basics 19-inch Propane Fire Pit Affiliate link
This Amazon Basics unit offers 55,000 BTU of heat in a 19-inch round design. It includes a carry strap, lid, lava rock, and a 10-foot gas hose. The steel construction features a black high-temperature finish. It weighs 19.8 pounds and fits on standard 20-pound LP tanks. You get a complete set for patio warmth. It suits those wanting a simple, portable propane option without extra bells and whistles.
Pros
- 55,000 BTU stainless steel burner
- Includes carry strap for transport
- Comes with lava rock and lid
- 10-foot gas hose with regulator
Cons
- 19-inch diameter is smaller than 21-24 inch competitors
- 55,000 BTU is lower than 58,000-60,000 BTU models
- No grill grate included for cooking
Good fit if
- You need a lightweight 19.8 lb unit for easy moving
- You want a complete set with lava rock and hose
- You prefer a simple round propane fire pit
Skip if
- You require a grill grate for cooking food
- You want more than 55,000 BTU of heat
- You need a larger 21-inch or bigger diameter
Verdict: Amazon Basics 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit provides reliable warmth for small patios. It fits buyers who prioritize portability and a complete accessory set over maximum heat output or cooking features.
BALI Outdoors 22-Inch Smokeless Fire Pit with Grill
Best for: Smokeless wood burning with cooking grate
- Fuel Type
- Wood, wood pellets
- Diameter or Width
- 22 inches
- Material
- Stainless steel
- Included Accessories
- Grill, poker
- Design
- Smokeless
- Features
- Cooking Grate
View on Amazon: BALI Outdoors 22-Inch Smokeless Fire Pit with Grill Affiliate link
This BALI Outdoors unit uses wood or burning pellets to create a smokeless flame. It measures 22 inches wide and 15 inches tall. The stainless steel body weighs 24.8 pounds. A cooking grate is included for outdoor meals. The three-legged base keeps the fire stable on patios. You get a durable, portable fire source without propane tanks.
Pros
- Smokeless design with advanced airflow technology
- Constructed from durable stainless steel
- Includes a grill grate for cooking
- Lightweight at 24.8 pounds for portability
- Three-legged base prevents ground heat damage
Cons
- Requires wood or pellets, not propane
- No remote or app control available
- Smaller 22-inch diameter than many alternatives
Good fit if
- You want a smokeless fire experience
- You prefer burning wood or pellets over gas
- You need a portable pit with a cooking grate
Skip if
- You require propane fuel for convenience
- You need a larger diameter fire pit
- You want electronic ignition or remote control
Verdict: BALI Outdoors 22 inch Smokeless Wood Fire Pit suits those who value smokeless combustion and cooking capability. It fits buyers who prefer wood fuel and do not need propane connectivity.
Florise 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit with 2 Grills
Best for: large wood fire gatherings with grilling needs
- Fuel Type
- Wood
- Diameter or Width
- 36 inches
- Material
- Metal
- Included Accessories
- Fire poker, 2 grills, lid
- Design
- Table
- Features
- Cooking Grate
View on Amazon: Florise 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit with 2 Grills Affiliate link
This 36-inch wood burning fire pit offers a large 36-inch diameter and 17.1-inch height for substantial heat output. It includes two cooking grills and a lid that doubles as a table. The metal construction weighs 27.1 pounds and holds up to 20 pounds of wood. It suits groups of five to eight people seeking a multifunctional outdoor centerpiece for gatherings.
Pros
- Large 36-inch diameter provides ample space for groups
- Includes two cooking grills for efficient barbecue preparation
- Lid converts the unit into a functional table
- Holds up to 20 pounds of wood for sustained warmth
Cons
- Uses wood fuel instead of propane, requiring more maintenance
- Heavier build at 27.1 pounds reduces portability
- No smokeless design, which may produce more smoke than other options
Good fit if
- You want a large fire pit that doubles as a cooking station
- You prefer the ambiance of a wood fire over propane
- You need a sturdy base with a fire ring for stability
Skip if
- You require a portable, lightweight unit for easy transport
- You want a smokeless fire pit for cleaner burning
- You prefer the convenience of propane fuel over wood
Verdict: Florise 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit is a robust, multifunctional option for those who prioritize cooking capacity and large-scale warmth. It fits well for backyard gatherings where wood fuel is acceptable and portability is not a priority.
Outland Living 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit
Best for: small decks and camping trips
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Heat Output
- 58,000 BTU/hr
- Diameter or Width
- 19 inches
- Material
- Steel, stainless steel
- Included Accessories
- 10-ft hose, regulator, lava rock set
- Design
- Smokeless
View on Amazon: Outland Living 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit Affiliate link
The Outland Living 19-inch Propane Firebowl delivers 58,000 BTU of heat in a compact 19-inch design. It weighs 22 pounds and stands 11 inches tall. The unit includes a 10-foot hose and regulator. It uses propane for a smokeless flame. This model suits small decks or camping trips. It fits users needing portable warmth without ash cleanup.
Pros
- 58,000 BTU heat output
- Compact 19-inch diameter
- Includes 10-ft hose and regulator
- Smokeless propane operation
- Lightweight 22-pound build
Cons
- 19-inch size is smaller than larger alternatives
- Propane tank not included
- No grill grate included
Good fit if
- You need a portable fire pit for small decks
- You want a smokeless flame for camping
- You prefer lightweight equipment under 25 pounds
Skip if
- You require a built-in grill grate
- You need a large 36-inch fire bowl
- You want a wood-burning fire pit
Verdict: Outland Living 19-inch Propane Firebowl fits small outdoor spaces well. It offers portable heat without smoke for camping or deck use.
Gasfargo 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit
Best for: portable cooking and high heat output
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Heat Output
- 60,000 BTU/hr
- Diameter or Width
- 19 in
- Ignition Type
- Manual
- Included Accessories
- Grill grate, cover, carry kit, hose
- Design
- Smokeless
View on Amazon: Gasfargo 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit Affiliate link
This Gasfargo unit delivers 60,000 BTU of heat in a 19-inch diameter design. It includes a cast iron cooking grate, a protective cover, and a 10-foot braided hose to keep your 20-lb tank at a safe distance. The manual ignition and enamel coating suit backyard patios or camping trips where smokeless warmth is needed.
Pros
- 60,000 BTU/hr heat output
- Includes cast iron cooking grate
- 10-foot braided stainless hose for safety
- Comes with protective cover and carry kit
Cons
- Requires manual ignition
- 19-inch diameter is smaller than 24-inch competitors
- Heavier build due to cast iron and enamel coating
Good fit if
- You need a smokeless propane option where wood fires are banned
- You want to cook food directly over the flame
- You need a portable unit for camping or RV trips
Skip if
- You prefer automatic push-button ignition
- You need a larger 24-inch diameter fire pit
- You want a lighter, more compact design for frequent travel
Verdict: Gasfargo 19-inch Portable Propane Fire Pit offers high heat and cooking utility for small groups. It fits buyers who prioritize BTU output and portability over automatic ignition or large footprints.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | EcoNook 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit with Grill | Ciays 21-Inch Propane Fire Pit with Grill Grate | Amazon Basics 19-inch Propane Fire Pit | BALI Outdoors 22-Inch Smokeless Fire Pit with Grill | Florise 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit with 2 Grills | Outland Living 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit | Gasfargo 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fuel Type | Propane | Propane | Propane | Wood, wood pellets | Wood | Propane | Propane |
| Heat Output | not stated | 58,000 BTU | 55,000 BTU | not stated | not stated | 58,000 BTU/hr | 60,000 BTU/hr |
| Diameter or Width | 24 inches | 20.7 inches | 19 inches | 22 inches | 36 inches | 19 inches | 19 in |
| Material | Steel, stainless steel | Metal | Steel | Stainless steel | Metal | Steel, stainless steel | not stated |
| Ignition Type | not stated | Piezo Electric Ignition | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | Manual |
| Included Accessories | Lid, grill, hose, regulator, lava rocks | Grate, 10 ft hose, lava rock, lid | Carry strap, lid, lava rock, gas hose | Grill, poker | Fire poker, 2 grills, lid | 10-ft hose, regulator, lava rock set | Grill grate, cover, carry kit, hose |
| Design | Smokeless | not stated | not stated | Smokeless | Table | Smokeless | Smokeless |
| Features | Cooking Grate | Cooking Grate | not stated | Cooking Grate | Cooking Grate | not stated | Protective Cover, Cooking Grate |
| Use | Garden, Camping | not stated | not stated | Backyard, Garden | Backyard, Camping | Backyard, Deck, Camping, RV | Backyard, Camping, RV |
| Color | Black | Black | Black | Black | Black | Black | Black |
| Shape | not stated | Round | Round | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Dimensions | 24 × 24 × 17.3 inches | 20.7 × 20.7 × 9.88 inches | 18.5 × 18.5 × 10.2 inches | 22 × 22 × 15 inches | 36 × 36 × 17.1 inches | 19 × 19 × 11 inches | 19 × 19 × 11 inches |
| Weight | 32 pounds | 23.9 pounds | 19.8 pounds | 24.8 pounds | 27.1 pounds | 22 pounds | not stated |
| Size | 24 INCH | 21 Inch | 19 inch | 22 inch | 36 Inch/2 Grill | 1 | not stated |
| Model | Portable Propane Fire Pits | CIFP02B-21-US | 63754 | not stated | not stated | 823 | FIRE PIT-001 |
Another guide worth a look: thor kitchen 24 inch liquid propane range alternatives.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a propane fire pit lighter than the EcoNook?
Yes. The Ciays 21-Inch model weighs 23.9 pounds, which is about 8 pounds less than the EcoNook. The Amazon Basics 19-Inch unit is even lighter at 19.8 pounds. Both are propane-powered and include cooking grates for flexible outdoor use.
Which alternative offers the highest heat output?
The Gasfargo 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit provides 60,000 BTU. This is the highest output listed. The Ciays and Outland Living models both offer 58,000 BTU. These units are suitable for users who prioritize maximum warmth and fast heating capabilities.
Can I use wood instead of propane with these options?
Yes. The BALI Outdoors 22-Inch and Florise 36-Inch models burn wood. The BALI unit features smokeless combustion technology. The Florise model includes two cooking grates. These are ideal if you prefer the ambiance of wood over the convenience of propane tanks.
Which fire pit is best for small decks?
The Outland Living 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit is designed for small decks. It measures 19 inches wide and weighs 22 pounds. Its compact size and smokeless design make it safe and practical for confined spaces like balconies or small patios.
Do any alternatives include a protective cover?
Yes. The Gasfargo 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit comes with a protective cover. This helps shield the unit from weather when not in use. Other models in this list do not list a cover as a standard included feature.
Which option is best for large gatherings?
The Florise 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit is the largest option. It measures 36 inches wide and includes two cooking grates. Its substantial size allows for large-scale warmth and ample cooking space, making it suitable for big backyard parties.
Are there portable propane options under 20 inches wide?
Yes. The Amazon Basics 19-Inch and Outland Living 19-Inch models both measure approximately 19 inches wide. The Gasfargo 19-Inch unit is also in this size range. These compact dimensions make them easy to store and move around small outdoor areas.