Concrete or Ceramic Fire Pits? Compared by Specs
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
Choosing between concrete vs ceramic fire pit options depends on your space and fuel needs. Both the AMS Elementi Manhattan and Ciays models serve as outdoor gas fire tables that blend heating with seating. The main difference lies in their construction materials and fuel sources. One uses heavy cast concrete with natural gas, while the other features a ceramic top with propane. Each design offers distinct benefits for different patio layouts.
Key differences
| Aspect | AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table | Ciays 43-Inch Ceramic Fire Pit Table |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Cast concrete | Ceramic, iron, Tefzel, stainless steel |
| Fuel Type | Natural Gas | Propane |
| Heat Output | not listed | 50,000 BTU |
| Weight | 173 pounds | 72.3 pounds |
| Dimensions | 36 x 36 x 36 inches | 42.9 x 24.6 x 25 inches |
| Ignition | Electronic ignition | Control dial |
Which one should you choose?
Choose AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table if
- You need a permanent natural gas connection for steady heat.
- You prefer a heavier, square table for a robust look.
- You want included lava rocks and a canvas cover.
Choose Ciays 43-Inch Ceramic Fire Pit Table if
- You need portable propane power for flexibility.
- You want a lighter table that is easier to move.
- You value a higher heat output of 50,000 BTU.
Verdict: Choose the AMS Elementi Manhattan if you have a fixed natural gas line and want a substantial, square concrete table. Pick the Ciays model if you need portable propane power, a lighter weight, and a higher heat output. Your choice depends on fuel availability and how much weight you can handle.
Concrete Versus Ceramic Fire Pit Specs
Fuel Type
The AMS Elementi Manhattan runs on natural gas, which connects directly to your home’s supply line for continuous fuel without refilling tanks. This setup suits permanent patio installations where convenience matters most. The Ciays 43-Inch Ceramic Fire Pit Table uses propane instead. Propane offers portability and independence from fixed gas lines, making it easier to move or store. If you have a dedicated natural gas line, the Elementi saves you from tank swaps. If you need flexibility or lack gas infrastructure, the Ciays propane system is the practical choice for your outdoor space.
Heat Output
The Ciays model specifies a heat output of 50,000 BTU, providing measurable warmth for your gathering. This figure helps you gauge how well it will warm a specific area. The AMS Elementi Manhattan does not list a BTU rating in its published specifications. Without this data, you cannot compare the raw thermal power of the concrete unit against the ceramic one. You must rely on general expectations for natural gas fire tables if you choose the Elementi. For those who prioritize verified heating performance data, the Ciays specification is clearer and more useful for planning your outdoor comfort.
Weight and Portability
Weight significantly impacts where you can place these fire tables. The AMS Elementi Manhattan weighs 173 pounds, reflecting the density of cast concrete. This mass ensures stability but makes the table difficult to move once positioned. It is best suited for a permanent location on a sturdy patio. The Ciays Ceramic Fire Pit Table weighs 72.3 pounds. This lighter build allows for easier repositioning if you rearrange your seating or need to store it. If you value a stationary, heavy-duty anchor, the concrete model wins. If you want to shift your fire pit occasionally, the ceramic option is more manageable.
Tabletop Material
The surface material defines the table's durability and maintenance needs. The Ciays features a premium ceramic tabletop composed of four sections. It resists high heat and dampness, wiping clean in seconds while showing delicate stone grain details. This material offers a sleek, upscale look suitable for modern patios. The AMS Elementi uses cast concrete for its construction. Concrete is robust and weather-resistant but typically requires sealing to prevent staining or moisture absorption. Ceramic provides a non-porous, easy-clean surface that stands up to spills. For low-maintenance daily use as a dining or coffee surface, the ceramic top is superior.
Dimensions and Footprint
Size determines how much space the fire pit occupies and how many people it can seat. The AMS Elementi Manhattan is a 36-inch square table, offering a compact footprint for smaller patios. Its height is 36 inches, which is standard for dining tables. The Ciays is larger at 43 inches long and 42.9 inches wide, with a lower height of 25 inches. This rectangular shape accommodates more guests, comfortably seating six people. The Ciays also includes a wind guard and decorative blue glass stones, adding visual depth. If you have a small balcony, the Elementi fits better. For larger gatherings, the Ciays provides more surface area and seating room.
Choose Your Ideal Concrete Or Ceramic Fire Pit
You want a permanent natural gas connection
The AMS Elementi Manhattan runs on natural gas, connecting directly to your home supply. This eliminates the need to refill propane tanks. It features electronic ignition for easy startup and includes a canvas cover for protection. Its cast concrete construction offers durability for a fixed patio installation where convenience is a priority.
You need high heat output and portability
The Ciays 43-Inch Ceramic Fire Pit delivers 50,000 BTU of heating power. It runs on propane, allowing you to move it easily without a fixed gas line. The unit weighs only 72.3 pounds, making it significantly lighter than concrete models. Its stainless steel burner provides steady flames for cold evenings.
You prefer a spacious rectangular design
The Ciays model measures 42.9 inches in length and 43 inches wide, offering a large rectangular surface. It seats six guests comfortably and doubles as a dining table with the included lid. The ceramic tabletop resists heat and dampness, wiping clean quickly. This shape suits larger patios or poolside areas perfectly.
Quick picks
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table | Natural gas patio setups | Check price of AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table on Amazon |
| 2 | Ciays 43-Inch Ceramic Fire Pit Table | patio dining and stable flame performance | Check price of Ciays 43-Inch Ceramic Fire Pit Table on Amazon |
The products compared
AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table
Best for: Natural gas patio setups
- Material
- Concrete (what this guide is about)
- Fuel Type
- Natural Gas
- Diameter or Width
- 36 inches
- Ignition Type
- Electronic ignition
- Included Accessories
- Canvas cover, lava rock
- Design
- Table
View on Amazon: AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table Affiliate link
This cast concrete fire table measures 36 by 36 inches with a 16-inch depth. It runs on natural gas and uses electronic ignition. The square design includes a canvas cover and lava rocks. You get a sturdy, heavy unit weighing 173 pounds. This model suits those who want a permanent gas connection and a solid, low-maintenance surface for their patio.
Pros
- Cast concrete construction for durability
- Electronic ignition system
- Includes canvas cover and lava rocks
- 36-inch square tabletop
Cons
- Heavy at 173 pounds
- Limited to natural gas fuel type
- No remote control mentioned
Good fit if
- You have a permanent natural gas line
- You prefer a heavy, stable table
- You want a square fire pit design
Skip if
- You need propane flexibility
- You want a lightweight portable unit
- You prefer a ceramic top
Verdict: AMS Fireplace Manhattan 36" Concrete Fire Table is a solid choice for patios with gas lines. It fits users who value heavy, durable concrete over ceramic tops.
Ciays 43-Inch Ceramic Fire Pit Table
Best for: patio dining and stable flame performance
- Material
- Ceramic (what this guide is about)
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Heat Output
- 50,000 BTU
- Diameter or Width
- 24.6 inches
- Included Accessories
- Glass wind guard, lid, glass rocks
- Mount Type
- Tabletop
View on Amazon: Ciays 43-Inch Ceramic Fire Pit Table Affiliate link
This Ciays fire table features a 43-inch rectangular ceramic top that resists heat and dampness. It delivers 50,000 BTU of heat output from a propane tank, supported by a stainless steel burner and iron frame. The unit includes a glass wind guard to stabilize flames. It measures 42.9 inches long and weighs 72.3 pounds. This design suits those who want a durable, high-output table for patios or decks.
Pros
- 43-inch ceramic tabletop resists high heat and dampness
- 50,000 BTU heating power with CSA safety certification
- Clear glass wind shield stabilizes flames in breezy weather
- H-type stainless steel burner produces steady flames
Cons
- Weighs 72.3 pounds, making it heavy to move
- No remote control or app connectivity listed
- Requires manual ignition via a control dial
Good fit if
- You need a high-output heat source for large gatherings
- You want a ceramic surface that is easy to clean
- You have a flat patio or deck for a 43-inch table
Skip if
- You prefer a concrete or ceramic fire pit without a table function
- You need a portable unit lighter than 72.3 pounds
- You want automatic ignition or remote flame adjustment
Verdict: Ciays 43 in Ceramic Gas Fire Table offers strong heating performance and a durable ceramic top for outdoor entertaining. It fits buyers who prioritize heat output and a cleanable surface over portability or smart controls.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table | Ciays 43-Inch Ceramic Fire Pit Table |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel Type | Natural Gas | Propane |
| Heat Output | not stated | 50,000 BTU |
| Diameter or Width | 36 inches | 24.6 inches |
| Material | Cast concrete | Ceramic, stainless steel, iron |
| Ignition Type | Electronic ignition | not stated |
| Included Accessories | Canvas cover, lava rock | Glass wind guard, lid, glass rocks |
| Mount Type | not stated | Tabletop |
| Design | Table | Table |
| Features | Protective Cover, Lava Rocks | Wind Guard |
| Shape | Square | Rectangular |
| Dimensions | 36 × 16 × 36 inches | 42.9 × 24.6 × 25 inches |
| Weight | 173 pounds | 72.3 pounds |
| Color | Manhattan - Dark Gray | Black-Rectangle |
| Size | not stated | 43 in with Ceramic Tabletop |
| Model | not stated | CIFPT79B-43-US |
Frequently asked questions
Is concrete or ceramic better for outdoor fire pits?
Concrete offers superior durability and weight, while ceramic provides a lighter alternative with easier cleaning. The AMS Elementi Manhattan uses concrete for a heavy, stable base that resists weathering. Ciays uses ceramic for a tabletop design that is simpler to maintain and move if needed.
Do concrete fire pits weigh more than ceramic ones?
Yes, concrete models are significantly heavier due to the density of the material. The AMS Elementi Manhattan weighs 173 pounds, providing a fixed, permanent feel for your patio. In contrast, the Ciays ceramic table weighs only 72.3 pounds, making it much easier to reposition.
Which fire pit material holds heat better?
Concrete generally retains heat longer due to its thermal mass, though both materials work well for gas units. The AMS Elementi concrete table provides steady warmth for natural gas setups. Ceramic tops heat up quickly and offer a clean surface, ideal for dining areas with stable flame performance.
Can I use a concrete fire pit on a deck?
You must check your deck’s weight limit before placing a concrete unit. The AMS Elementi Manhattan weighs 173 pounds, which may exceed standard deck capacities. A ceramic option like the Ciays model weighs 72.3 pounds, posing less risk to structural supports while still delivering reliable heating.
How do I clean a ceramic fire pit table?
Ceramic surfaces are non-porous and easy to wipe down after use. The Ciays 43-Inch Ceramic Fire Pit Table features a smooth top that resists soot buildup. Concrete surfaces may require more careful maintenance to prevent staining, as seen in the textured finish of the AMS Elementi Manhattan.
What shape options are available for concrete and ceramic pits?
Both materials come in various shapes to fit different patio layouts. The AMS Elementi Manhattan is a square concrete table measuring 36 inches on each side. The Ciays ceramic option is rectangular, measuring 42.9 inches in length, offering more linear seating space for outdoor dining groups.