EcoNook 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire vs EcoNook 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire (2026): Key Differences
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You are comparing the econook 36 inch wood burning fire vs 24 inch portable propane fire. Both units feature a cooking grate and a protective lid. They share a steel construction designed for outdoor use. The main difference lies in their fuel source and size. One uses wood for a traditional experience. The other runs on propane for convenience. This choice affects portability, cleanup, and heat output. You need to decide which method fits your outdoor routine best.
Key differences
| Aspect | EcoNook 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit with Grill | EcoNook 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit with Grill |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel Type | Wood | Propane |
| Diameter | 36 inches | 24 inches |
| Height | 25.6 inches | 17.3 inches |
| Weight | 41.4 pounds | 32 pounds |
| Portability Features | Fixed legs | Foldable legs, carrying handle |
Which one should you choose?
Choose EcoNook 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit with Grill if
- You want a larger diameter for bigger gatherings
- You prefer the traditional experience of burning wood
- You need a unit that can double as a 30.5 inch table
Choose EcoNook 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit with Grill if
- You want a smaller footprint for compact spaces
- You need a lightweight unit with foldable legs for easy transport
- You prefer a smokeless flame that requires no firewood
Verdict: The 36-inch wood model suits those who value size and traditional ambiance. The 24-inch propane model is better for portability and quick setup. Choose based on whether you prioritize seating space or ease of movement.
EcoNook Fire Pit Comparison Guide
Fuel type
Product A burns wood, requiring you to source, split, and store firelogs. You must manage ash cleanup after each use and ensure the fire is fully extinguished before leaving it. Product B uses propane, connecting to a standard 32-lb tank via an included 8.5-ft hose. You adjust the flame height with a valve knob. There is no ash to sweep and no smoke to deal with. Propane offers immediate ignition without matches or starters, making it cleaner and more convenient for quick outdoor gatherings.
Size and footprint
Product A has a 36-inch diameter, creating a large central gathering point. The actual usable width is 30.5 inches. It stands 25.6 inches tall, providing a substantial presence on your patio. Product B is smaller, with a 24-inch diameter and 24-inch width. It stands only 17.3 inches tall. The smaller footprint of Product B makes it easier to fit on compact decks or in tight corners. Product A offers more seating space around the fire, while Product B saves floor space.
Portability
Product A weighs 41.4 pounds. It has four fixed legs and requires assembly with screws. You need tools to set it up, and it stays in one place once installed. Product B weighs 32 pounds, making it lighter. It features foldable legs for efficient storage and a handle on the lid for easy carrying. You can move Product B without a bag. It is designed for transport to camping, RVs, or tailgating. Product A is a permanent fixture, while Product B is built for mobility.
Cooking features
Both units include a cooking grate for grilling. Product A comes with a log grate for wood burning and a metal lid that doubles as a 30.5-inch round table. You can cook over wood or use the lid for dining. Product B includes a mesh screen to prevent sparks and lava rocks to enhance the flame effect. It also has a gas tank support to keep the cylinder upright. Product A offers a larger surface area for the table function, while Product B focuses on safe, contained gas cooking.
Safety and design
Product A has a black and gold patina finish with a retro pattern lid. It includes a rain-proof cover and a fire poker for moving wood. The weight and four legs improve stability on uneven ground. Product B is black with a protective steel finish. It includes a mesh screen to contain flames and a regulator for safe gas flow. It is spark-free, which helps comply with fire bans in forested areas. Product A requires fire management, while Product B offers a controlled, spark-free flame for safer use in restricted zones.
Which EcoNook Fire Pit Fits You
You want a permanent patio centerpiece
This 36-inch model offers a larger footprint for gatherings. The 30.5-inch diameter provides ample space for seating around the fire. Its 41.4-pound weight and four-leg design improve stability on uneven ground. The included lid doubles as a 30.5-inch round table, extending its utility beyond just heating.
You need easy portability and cleanup
Weighing only 32 pounds, this unit is significantly lighter than the wood option. The foldable legs allow for compact storage and easy transport. You avoid ash cleanup entirely by using propane. The handle on the lid lets you carry it without a bag, making it ideal for tailgating or camping.
You prefer smoke-free ambiance
Propane combustion produces no smoke or sparks, keeping your patio clean. The mesh screen prevents flames from flying out, enhancing safety. You get a clean burn without the need to source firewood or manage a chimney effect. The natural lava rocks enhance the flickering visual effect without the associated debris.
You want versatile outdoor cooking
The 36-inch wood-burning model includes a dedicated cooking grate and log grate. Its larger size accommodates more food for barbecues. The high-temperature powder coating ensures durability during cooking sessions. You can roast meat over wood fire while enjoying the traditional bonfire experience, combining heating and cooking in one sturdy 25.6-inch tall unit.
The products compared
EcoNook 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit with Grill
Best for: Wood fire lovers needing a grill and table
- Fuel Type
- Wood
- Diameter or Width
- 30.5 inches
- Included Accessories
- Grill, lid, fire poker, rain cover
- Design
- Table
- Features
- Protective Cover, Cooking Grate
- Shape
- Round
View on Amazon: EcoNook 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit with Grill Affiliate link
This 36-inch wood fire pit offers three functions: bonfire, barbecue, and table. It measures 30.5 inches wide and 25.6 inches tall. The unit weighs 41.4 pounds and includes a cooking grate, lid, and log grate. The gold and black finish adds style. You can use it for gatherings of four to six people. It provides a stable base with four legs.
Pros
- Three-in-one design serves as a fire pit, grill, and table
- Large 36-inch diameter accommodates groups of four to six
- Includes cooking grate for outdoor barbecue
- Sturdy four-leg base improves stability on uneven ground
- Coated with high-temperature powder for rust resistance
Cons
- Heavier at 41.4 pounds, making it less portable
- Requires wood fuel, limiting fuel flexibility
- Assembly requires careful screw tightening to ensure stability
Good fit if
- You want a multi-functional fire pit for cooking and dining
- You prefer the ambiance of a wood-burning fire
- You have a permanent spot for a larger fire pit
Skip if
- You need a portable fire pit for easy moving
- You prefer propane or gas fuel for convenience
- You have limited patio space for a 36-inch unit
Verdict: EcoNook 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit is a sturdy, multi-use option for those who enjoy cooking over wood. It fits well in larger patios where its weight and size are not a concern. You will appreciate the included grill and table lid.
EcoNook 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit with Grill
Best for: small patios and portable camping use
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Diameter or Width
- 24 inches
- Material
- Steel, stainless steel
- Included Accessories
- Lid, grill, hose, regulator, lava rocks
- Design
- Smokeless
- Features
- Cooking Grate
View on Amazon: EcoNook 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit with Grill Affiliate link
This 24-inch propane fire pit offers a smokeless flame using standard 32-lb tanks. It weighs 32 pounds with foldable legs for easy transport. The unit includes a cooking grate, mesh screen, and lava rocks. Its steel construction and protective finish ensure durability. You will appreciate the included hose and regulator for safe, controlled heat. This model suits those seeking a compact, portable outdoor heating solution.
Pros
- 24-inch diameter provides ample heat coverage
- Foldable legs and lightweight 32-pound design for portability
- Includes cooking grate for BBQ use
- Pre-attached 8.5-foot hose keeps tank safely out of sight
Cons
- 24-inch size is smaller than the 36-inch wood-burning alternative
- Requires a separate 32-lb propane tank
- No remote control or electronic ignition specified
Good fit if
- You need a compact fire pit for patios or camping
- You want to cook food using the included grill grate
- You prefer a smokeless, spark-free flame option
Skip if
- You require a larger 36-inch fire pit diameter
- You want to burn wood instead of using propane
- You need a built-in propane tank storage compartment
Verdict: EcoNook 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit fits users who prioritize portability and cooking versatility in a compact footprint. It is ideal for small outdoor spaces where a wood-burning pit is not feasible.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | EcoNook 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit with Grill | EcoNook 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit with Grill |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel Type | Wood | Propane |
| Diameter or Width | 30.5 inches | 24 inches |
| Material | not stated | Steel, stainless steel |
| Included Accessories | Grill, lid, fire poker, rain cover | Lid, grill, hose, regulator, lava rocks |
| Design | Table | Smokeless |
| Features | Protective Cover, Cooking Grate | Cooking Grate |
| Use | not stated | Garden, Camping |
| Color | Gold&Black[with Grill] | Black |
| Shape | Round | not stated |
| Dimensions | 30.5 × 30.5 × 25.6 inches | 24 × 24 × 17.3 inches |
| Weight | 41.4 pounds | 32 pounds |
| Model | wood burning fire pit with grill | Portable Propane Fire Pits |
| Size | not stated | 24 INCH |
Frequently asked questions
Which EcoNook fire pit is better for small patios?
The EcoNook 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit is better for small patios. Its 24-inch width and 24-inch length fit compact spaces. It weighs only 32 pounds, making it easy to move. The wood-burning model is larger at 30.5 inches and heavier at 41.4 pounds. It requires more floor space and is harder to reposition.
Do both models include a cooking grate?
Yes, both the EcoNook 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit and the 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit include a cooking grate. This allows you to cook food over the heat source. The wood-burning version is available in a gold and black color with the grill. The propane model comes in black. Both support outdoor cooking versatility.
How much weight can these fire pits handle?
The EcoNook 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit weighs 41.4 pounds. The EcoNook 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit weighs 32 pounds. These weights reflect the steel construction and included accessories like the grill and lid. The heavier wood-burning unit offers more stability on uneven ground. The lighter propane model is easier to transport for camping or moving.
What are the dimensions of the EcoNook 36-inch model?
The EcoNook 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit measures 30.5 inches in width and 30.5 inches in length. Its height is 25.6 inches. These dimensions provide a substantial footprint for larger patios. The larger size accommodates more seating around the fire. It is designed for users who prioritize a permanent, sturdy centerpiece for outdoor gatherings.
Is the propane model suitable for camping?
The EcoNook 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit is suitable for camping. Its compact 24-inch size and 32-pound weight make it portable. You can connect it to a standard propane tank. This model is ideal for small outdoor spaces or temporary setups. It offers cooking versatility without the need to manage wood or ash cleanup.
Which model is better for cooking over wood?
The EcoNook 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit is better for cooking over wood. It features a dedicated cooking grate and is designed for wood fuel. This model suits users who enjoy the flavor and process of wood fires. It includes a table lid for added utility. The propane model uses gas, which does not provide the same wood-fired cooking experience.
How do the heights of the two models compare?
The EcoNook 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit stands 25.6 inches tall. The EcoNook 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit is 17.3 inches tall. The wood-burning model is significantly taller, which may affect seating comfort and wind exposure. The propane model is lower, making it more compact. Choose the height that fits your patio furniture and safety needs.
Can I use both models for outdoor dining?
Yes, both models support outdoor dining. The EcoNook 36-Inch Wood Burning Fire Pit includes a grill and table lid. The EcoNook 24-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit also includes a cooking grate. Both allow you to prepare meals outdoors. The wood-burning model offers a larger surface area for cooking. The propane model provides a convenient alternative for gas-powered cooking.