Onlyfire Outdoor Living 19.5” Smokeless Fire Pit or Onlyfire Outdoor Living 15.7" Propane Gas Fire? Which Onlyfire Outdoor Living Model to Buy
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
This onlyfire outdoor living 19 5 smokeless fire pit vs 15 7 propane gas comparison helps you pick the right fire solution. Both models come from Onlyfire Outdoor Living and offer portable outdoor warmth. The main difference lies in their fuel source and design. One uses propane for instant, clean heat, while the other burns wood or charcoal for a traditional experience. You need to decide which heating method fits your outdoor space better.
Key differences
| Aspect | Onlyfire 15.7-Inch Square Propane Tabletop Fire Pit | Onlyfire 19.5" Smokeless Fire Pit |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel Type | Propane | Wood, charcoal |
| Mount Type | Tabletop | Portable floor unit |
| Heat Output | 23,000 BTUs / 40,000 BTU | not listed |
| Weight | 15 pounds | 19.8 pounds |
| Included Accessories | Propane hose, wind guards, lava rocks | Carrying bag, ash pan |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Onlyfire 15.7-Inch Square Propane Tabletop Fire Pit if
- You want instant heat with adjustable flame control.
- You need a compact unit for dining tables or countertops.
- You prefer a clean burn without smoke or ash cleanup.
Choose Onlyfire 19.5" Smokeless Fire Pit if
- You enjoy the traditional ambiance of a wood fire.
- You want a smokeless design with double-walled airflow.
- You need a detachable unit for easy storage and transport.
Verdict: Choose the propane model if you value convenience, quick setup, and clean burning. Select the smokeless wood fire pit if you prefer the authentic look of burning wood and need a detachable design for storage.
Propane vs Smokeless Fire Pit
Fuel source
The Onlyfire 15.7-Inch Square Propane Tabletop Fire Pit uses propane gas. It connects to a standard 20 lb tank. You get instant heat with adjustable flame control. There is no smoke, soot, or ash. The Onlyfire 19.5" Smokeless Fire Pit burns wood or charcoal. You must gather fuel and manage the fire. It produces a traditional wood fire experience. Propane offers convenience and clean burning. Wood burning provides a classic campfire feel. Choose propane for easy setup. Choose wood for a traditional outdoor fire.
Heat output
The propane fire pit delivers 40,000 BTU of heat output. It uses a high-efficiency stainless steel burner. This provides powerful and consistent warmth quickly. The smokeless wood pit does not list a BTU rating. It relies on double-walled construction to concentrate flames. The wood model focuses on durability and airflow. The propane model focuses on measurable heat power. If you need specific warmth levels, the propane unit has clear specs. The wood unit relies on combustion efficiency. Propane wins for defined heat performance.
Mount type
The propane fire pit is designed for tabletop mounting. It fits on dining tables, countertops, and outdoor desks. Its compact size suits small spaces. The smokeless fire pit sits directly on the ground. It is designed for patio, camping, or beach use. It is not a tabletop unit. The propane model offers versatility for elevated surfaces. The wood model requires ground space. If you have limited floor space, the tabletop option is better. If you have open ground, the wood pit works well. This is a clear difference in placement.
Design and portability
The propane fire pit weighs 15 pounds. It is lightweight and portable. The smokeless fire pit weighs 19.8 pounds. It features a detachable design for easy storage. It comes with a carrying bag. The wood pit splits into halves for transport. The propane unit is smaller and lighter. The wood unit is larger but includes a bag. Both are portable. The propane model is easier to move due to lower weight. The wood model requires more effort to carry. Propane wins for lighter weight.
Size and footprint
The propane fire pit measures 15.7 inches wide. It is square and compact. The smokeless fire pit measures 19.7 inches wide. It is larger and cylindrical. The wood pit takes up more space. The propane model fits on smaller tables. The wood model needs a larger ground area. If space is tight, the propane unit is better. If you want a larger fire, the wood unit is better. The size difference is significant. Choose based on your available space. The propane model is more compact.
Included accessories
The propane fire pit includes a propane hose, glass wind guards, and lava rocks. It is ready to use with a tank. The smokeless fire pit includes a carrying bag and an ash pan. The ash pan collects loose ash. The propane unit has more fire-specific accessories. The wood unit has storage accessories. Both include essential items for their type. The propane model needs a separate tank. The wood model needs wood or charcoal. The included items differ based on fuel type. Neither is clearly better without context.
Which Onlyfire Fire Pit Suits Your Needs
You want a tabletop propane fire pit
This 15.7-inch square unit sits on tables or countertops. It delivers 23,000 BTUs of heat using propane gas. You get instant warmth without smoke or ash. The lightweight 15-pound build makes it easy to move. Included lava rocks and glass guards create a modern flame display for your patio.
You prefer a smokeless wood-burning option
This 19.5-inch stainless steel pit burns wood or charcoal. Its double-walled design circulates air to reduce smoke and sparks. An ash pan simplifies cleanup. The detachable construction fits into a carrying bag. Weighing 19.8 pounds, it offers a traditional fire experience for camping or backyard gatherings.
You need a compact portable solution
At just 15.7 inches wide and 15 pounds, this propane model is highly portable. It connects to a standard 20 lb tank for consistent fuel. The side-mounted design fits small spaces like dining tables. You enjoy adjustable flame control and clean burning. It is ideal for tailgates or small patios where space is limited.
The products compared
Onlyfire 15.7-Inch Square Propane Tabletop Fire Pit
Best for: small tabletop spaces and portable warmth
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Heat Output
- 40,000 BTU
- Diameter or Width
- 15.7 inches
- Included Accessories
- Hose, glass wind guards, lava rocks
- Mount Type
- Tabletop
- Design
- Smokeless
View on Amazon: Onlyfire 15.7-Inch Square Propane Tabletop Fire Pit Affiliate link
This tabletop propane fire pit measures 15.7 inches wide and weighs 15 pounds. It delivers 40,000 BTUs of heat through a stainless steel burner. The square design fits dining tables or countertops. You get lava rocks and wind guards included. It requires a standard 20 lb propane tank, which is not included. This model suits small outdoor spaces where portability matters.
Pros
- 40,000 BTU heat output for quick warming
- Compact 15.7-inch square footprint for tabletops
- Includes lava rocks and glass wind guards
- Lightweight 15-pound portable build
Cons
- Requires separate 20 lb propane tank purchase
- No remote control or electronic ignition listed
- Limited to tabletop or side-mount use only
Good fit if
- You need a heat source for a dining table
- You want a lightweight unit for easy transport
- You prefer clean-burning propane over wood smoke
Skip if
- You need a large fire pit for a patio floor
- You want a smokeless wood-burning fire experience
- You prefer a round fire pit shape
Verdict: Onlyfire 15.7" Propane Tabletop Fire Pit delivers strong 40,000 BTU heat in a compact 15-pound package. It fits buyers who need portable warmth for tables or small decks rather than large open areas.
Onlyfire 19.5" Smokeless Fire Pit
Best for: Smokeless wood burning and portable storage
- Fuel Type
- Wood
- Diameter or Width
- 19.5 inches
- Material
- Stainless steel
- Ash Cleanout
- Ash pan
- Included Accessories
- Carrying bag
- Design
- Smokeless
View on Amazon: Onlyfire 19.5" Smokeless Fire Pit Affiliate link
This 19.7-inch stainless steel fire pit burns wood or charcoal. Its double-walled design circulates air to reduce smoke and sparks. The detachable construction allows it to fold in half for storage in the included carrying bag. Weighing 19.8 pounds, it is portable for RVs or camping. It suits you if you want a smokeless option that packs away easily.
Pros
- Double-walled stainless steel construction reduces smoke and sparks
- Detachable design folds for compact storage in the carrying bag
- Includes an ash pan for easier cleanup and airflow management
Cons
- Requires wood or charcoal fuel instead of propane
- Heavier at 19.8 pounds than typical tabletop propane units
- Manual lighting required with no electronic ignition
Good fit if
- You want a smokeless wood-burning experience
- You need a fire pit that folds for travel
- You prefer the smell of real wood fire
Skip if
- You want instant push-button propane ignition
- You prefer a lighter, non-detachable unit
- You want to avoid handling wood or charcoal
Verdict: Onlyfire 19.5" Smokeless Fire Pit fits you if you prioritize a smokeless wood-burning experience and easy transport. The detachable design and ash pan make it a practical choice for camping or small patios.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Onlyfire 15.7-Inch Square Propane Tabletop Fire Pit | Onlyfire 19.5" Smokeless Fire Pit |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel Type | Propane | Wood |
| Heat Output | 40,000 BTU | not stated |
| Diameter or Width | 15.7 inches | 19.5 inches |
| Material | not stated | Stainless steel |
| Ash Cleanout | not stated | Ash pan |
| Included Accessories | Hose, glass wind guards, lava rocks | Carrying bag |
| Mount Type | Tabletop | not stated |
| Design | Smokeless | Smokeless |
| Features | Lava Rocks | not stated |
| Use | Backyard, Camping, RV | Backyard, Camping |
| Color | Black | Silver FP036 |
| Shape | Square | not stated |
| Dimensions | 16 × 16 × 5 inches | 19.7 × 19.7 × 15.7 inches |
| Weight | 15 pounds | 19.8 pounds |
| Size | 15.7" | not stated |
| Model | FP040 | FP036 |
Frequently asked questions
Which Onlyfire fire pit is better for small tabletops?
The Onlyfire 15.7-Inch Square Propane Tabletop Fire Pit is the better choice for small spaces. It measures 15.7 inches across and weighs only 15 pounds. This compact size allows it to sit securely on tables or small decks. You get portable warmth without taking up much room. The square shape fits neatly into tight areas where larger pits cannot go.
Does the Onlyfire 19.5 smokeless fire pit use gas?
No, the Onlyfire 19.5" Smokeless Fire Pit does not use gas. It is designed for wood burning. This model focuses on a smokeless experience using natural fuel. You do not need propane tanks or gas lines. The design prioritizes a traditional fire feel without the smoke. It is ideal if you prefer burning wood over using propane for your outdoor heat source.
How heavy is the Onlyfire 15.7 propane fire pit?
The Onlyfire 15.7-Inch Square Propane Tabletop Fire Pit weighs 15 pounds. This light weight makes it easy to move around your patio or deck. You can carry it from one spot to another without strain. The compact build ensures it does not overwhelm small spaces. This portability is a key feature for buyers who need a flexible heating solution.
What are the dimensions of the Onlyfire 19.5 smokeless pit?
The Onlyfire 19.5" Smokeless Fire Pit measures 19.7 inches in width and length. Its height is 15.7 inches. This model weighs 19.8 pounds. The slightly larger footprint compared to the propane version provides more burning space. The dimensions allow it to fit on standard patios or camping sites while maintaining a sturdy presence.
Can I use the Onlyfire propane pit on a table?
Yes, the Onlyfire 15.7-Inch Square Propane Tabletop Fire Pit is designed for tabletop use. Its mount type is specifically listed as tabletop. The 16-inch width and 5-inch height make it stable on flat surfaces. You can place it on dining tables or side tables. This design allows you to enjoy warmth directly at your seating level.
Is the Onlyfire 19.5 model good for camping?
The Onlyfire 19.5" Smokeless Fire Pit is suitable for camping due to its portable design. It weighs 19.8 pounds and features a detachable construction. This makes transport and storage easier when you are on the move. The smokeless wood-burning technology provides a clean fire experience in outdoor settings. It is a practical option for campers who want a traditional fire.
What color is the Onlyfire 15.7 propane fire pit?
The Onlyfire 15.7-Inch Square Propane Tabletop Fire Pit comes in black. This color option provides a sleek and modern look for your outdoor space. The black finish complements most patio furniture and decor styles. It is a versatile choice that blends well with various aesthetic preferences. The color is consistent across the square tabletop design.