Propane vs Natural Gas Fire Pits: Which Should You Buy?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
Choosing between a propane vs natural gas fire pit depends on your setup and heating needs. Both models offer table designs for outdoor gatherings, but their fuel sources differ significantly. One runs on propane tanks for portable use, while the other connects to a fixed natural gas line. We compare their heat output, materials, and included accessories to help you decide which fits your patio best.
Key differences
| Aspect | Ciays 42-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table | AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel Type | Propane | Natural Gas |
| Heat Output | 60,000 BTU | not listed |
| Material | Steel lid | Cast concrete |
| Ignition | Manual | Electronic ignition |
| Weight | 65 pounds | 173 pounds |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Ciays 42-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table if
- You need high heat output for larger gatherings, as this model provides 60,000 BTU.
- You want a lighter unit that is easier to move, weighing only 65 pounds.
- You prefer the flexibility of a propane tank that does not require a fixed gas line.
Choose AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table if
- You want the convenience of electronic ignition for easy startup.
- You prefer a durable cast concrete construction that feels more permanent.
- You have a natural gas line available and want to avoid refilling tanks.
Verdict: The propane model suits you if you prioritize high heat output and portability. The natural gas option is better if you value permanent installation and electronic ignition. Your choice depends on whether you need flexible fuel or a fixed connection.
Propane Versus Natural Gas Fire Pits
Fuel Type
The Ciays model runs on propane, requiring a standard tank connection. This setup offers portability, allowing you to move the table if needed, though you must monitor fuel levels. The Elementi Manhattan uses natural gas, connecting directly to your home’s fixed line. This means no refilling or swapping tanks, providing continuous heat without interruption. Your choice depends on whether you prefer the flexibility of propane or the convenience of an always-available natural gas supply.
Heat Output
Ciays specifies a heat output of 60,000 BTU. This high output is designed to warm a larger area and keep food warm during gatherings. The Elementi Manhattan does not list a specific BTU rating in the provided data. Without this number, it is difficult to compare the raw thermal power directly. You should assume the Ciays offers a measurable, high-output heat source, while the Elementi’s warmth level remains unspecified in these specifications.
Build Material
Ciays features a steel lid and construction, weighing 65 pounds. Steel is durable but lighter, making it easier to reposition. The Elementi Manhattan is made of cast concrete and weighs 173 pounds. This heavy material offers superior heat retention and a premium, solid feel. The concrete also provides weather resistance. If you want a permanent, heavy-duty piece that stays in place, the concrete build is the stronger option.
Ignition Type
The Elementi Manhattan includes electronic ignition for reliable, one-touch lighting. This feature simplifies operation and ensures consistent starts. The Ciays model does not list an ignition type in the data, though it mentions an external fire level control. This suggests manual lighting or a simpler control mechanism. For ease of use and consistent starting, the electronic ignition on the Elementi provides a clear operational advantage.
Design and Size
Ciays offers a 42-inch diameter round table, providing ample space for drinks and snacks. It includes a steel lid for protection. The Elementi Manhattan is a 36-inch square table made of dark gray concrete. The square shape may fit differently in your space. The Ciays is larger in diameter, while the Elementi is more compact but heavier. Your choice depends on whether you prefer a larger round surface or a smaller, solid square design.
Choose the Right Fire Pit for You
Renters needing portable heat without installation
The Ciays model runs on propane, so you do not need a fixed gas line. This allows you to move the 65-pound unit easily. It delivers 60,000 BTU of heat, warming your space effectively. The steel lid protects the lava rocks when not in use, keeping your patio area tidy and safe.
Homeowners wanting permanent natural gas connection
The Elementi Manhattan connects directly to your home's natural gas supply. This eliminates the need to refill tanks or store them. The electronic ignition starts the fire instantly with a switch. The cast concrete construction provides a durable, permanent fixture for your outdoor living space that requires minimal maintenance over time.
Users seeking a heavy, durable concrete table
This unit weighs 173 pounds, making it very stable and resistant to wind. The cast concrete material offers superior durability compared to steel options. Its square 36-inch design provides ample surface area for food and drinks. The included canvas cover protects the unit from weather elements when not in use, extending its lifespan.
Guests preferring a lighter, wider surface
The Ciays table features a 42-inch diameter, offering more surface space than the 36-inch Elementi model. At 65 pounds, it is significantly lighter and easier to reposition. The black steel construction includes a lid and lava rocks for aesthetic appeal. This size is ideal for larger groups who need room for plates and beverages while enjoying the heat.
Quick picks
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ciays 42-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table | large patio dining and high heat | Check price of Ciays 42-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table on Amazon |
| 2 | AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table | permanent natural gas patio setups | Check price of AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table on Amazon |
The products compared
Ciays 42-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table
Best for: large patio dining and high heat
- Fuel Type
- Propane (what this guide is about)
- Heat Output
- 60,000 BTU
- Diameter or Width
- 20 inches
- Included Accessories
- Steel lid, lava rocks
- Design
- Table
- Use
- Backyard, Garden, Deck
View on Amazon: Ciays 42-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table Affiliate link
This Ciays propane fire pit table offers 60,000 BTU of heat output for outdoor gatherings. The 42-inch diameter surface provides ample space for food and drinks. It includes a steel lid for protection and lava rocks for visual appeal. The unit weighs 65 pounds and stands 24.4 inches high. You get a practical table design that combines heating with a dining surface. It suits those who want a central focal point for patio parties.
Pros
- 60,000 BTU heat output
- 42-inch wide table surface
- Includes steel lid and lava rocks
- External fire level control
Cons
- Propane only, no natural gas option
- 65 pounds weight requires two people
- No remote control included
Good fit if
- You need a central table for patio dining
- You want high heat output for cold evenings
- You prefer propane fuel flexibility
Skip if
- You require natural gas connectivity
- You need a remote control for operation
- You want a smaller footprint under 40 inches
Verdict: Ciays 42 Inch Propane Fire Pit Table delivers strong heat and a large surface for gatherings. It fits buyers who prioritize dining space and high BTU output over remote convenience.
AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table
Best for: permanent natural gas patio setups
- Fuel Type
- Natural Gas (what this guide is about)
- Diameter or Width
- 36 inches
- Material
- Cast concrete
- Ignition Type
- Electronic ignition
- Included Accessories
- Canvas cover, lava rock
- Design
- Table
View on Amazon: AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table Affiliate link
This square fire table is built from cast concrete and runs on natural gas. It measures 36 inches wide and weighs 173 pounds. The unit includes an electronic ignition, a canvas cover, and lava rocks. You get a durable, heavy-duty piece for your patio. It suits those who want a permanent, low-maintenance heat source without refueling tanks.
Pros
- Natural gas fuel type for continuous heat
- Durable cast concrete construction
- Electronic ignition system
- Includes canvas cover and lava rocks
Cons
- Heavy weight at 173 pounds
- Requires fixed natural gas line connection
- Limited height options compared to propane models
Good fit if
- You have a permanent natural gas line installed
- You prefer a heavy, stable table over a portable one
- You want a square design that matches modern patio furniture
Skip if
- You need to move the fire pit frequently
- You only have propane tanks available
- You want a lightweight unit for easy storage
Verdict: AMS Fireplace Manhattan 36" Natural Gas Fire Table is a solid choice for homeowners with existing gas lines who value durability. It fits best in spaces where a permanent, heavy fixture is acceptable.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Ciays 42-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table | AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel Type | Propane | Natural Gas |
| Heat Output | 60,000 BTU | not stated |
| Diameter or Width | 20 inches | 36 inches |
| Material | not stated | Cast concrete |
| Ignition Type | not stated | Electronic ignition |
| Included Accessories | Steel lid, lava rocks | Canvas cover, lava rock |
| Design | Table | Table |
| Features | Lava Rocks | Protective Cover, Lava Rocks |
| Use | Backyard, Garden, Deck | not stated |
| Color | Black | Manhattan - Dark Gray |
| Shape | not stated | Square |
| Dimensions | 43.3 × 20 × 24.4 inches | 36 × 16 × 36 inches |
| Weight | 65 pounds | 173 pounds |
| Size | 42 Inch with Lid | not stated |
| Model | CIFPT5B | not stated |
Frequently asked questions
Can I use a propane fire pit on a deck?
Yes, you can use propane models on decks. The Ciays 42-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table is designed for use on decks, gardens, and backyards. Its steel construction and portable tank setup make it suitable for various outdoor surfaces. Always check your specific deck material and local fire codes before placing any heat source on elevated structures.
How much space does a propane fire pit table need?
You need sufficient clearance around the unit for safety and airflow. The Ciays model measures 43.3 inches in length and 20 inches in width. It weighs 65 pounds, which is manageable for most patio layouts. Ensure you have enough room to access the propane tank and maintain safe distances from walls or furniture.
Is natural gas fire pit installation difficult?
Installation requires a professional to connect the unit to your home’s gas line. The AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table is a permanent fixture weighing 173 pounds. It cannot be moved once installed. You must have an existing natural gas line nearby, and a licensed technician should handle the final connection to ensure safety.
Which fire pit provides more heat output?
The Ciays propane model offers 60,000 BTU of heat output. This high output warms large outdoor dining areas effectively. The natural gas Elementi model does not list a specific BTU rating in its specifications. Generally, propane units can deliver intense heat quickly, while natural gas units provide steady, consistent warmth for permanent setups.
Do I need a cover for a concrete fire pit?
Using a protective cover is recommended to extend the life of the unit. The AMS Elementi Manhattan includes a protective cover in its features. Concrete can crack in freezing temperatures if water gets inside. Keeping the cover on when the fire pit is not in use protects the material from weather damage and debris.
Can I move a natural gas fire pit after installation?
No, you cannot move a natural gas fire pit once it is connected. The AMS Elementi Manhattan weighs 173 pounds and is designed as a permanent fixture. It connects directly to a fixed gas line. Relocating it would require disconnecting the gas supply and reinstalling it elsewhere, which is not practical for most homeowners.
What material is best for a fire pit table?
Material choice depends on your aesthetic and durability needs. The Ciays propane table is made of steel, which is lightweight and easy to move. The AMS natural gas table is made of concrete, offering a heavy, permanent feel. Steel is often preferred for portability, while concrete provides a solid, high-end look for fixed patio spaces.