Steel vs Concrete Fire Pits in 2026: Key Differences
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When you weigh steel vs concrete fire pit options, you are choosing between two durable outdoor materials. Both Ciays and Elementi models serve as functional heat sources for patios. They share a table design and use gas fuel. The main difference lies in their construction material and fuel type. Ciays uses steel and propane, while Elementi uses cast concrete and natural gas. These choices affect weight, installation, and maintenance. You need to decide which setup fits your outdoor space.
Key differences
| Aspect | Ciays 42-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table | AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Steel | Cast concrete |
| Fuel Type | Propane | Natural Gas |
| Ignition | Manual (implied by simple connection) | Electronic ignition |
| Weight | 65 pounds | 173 pounds |
| Dimensions | 42-inch diameter, 24.4 inches height | 36-inch square, 36 inches height |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Ciays 42-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table if
- You prefer a lighter unit that is easier to move around the patio.
- You want the flexibility to use a portable propane tank rather than a fixed line.
- You need a larger surface area for serving food and drinks.
Choose AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table if
- You want a permanent installation connected to a natural gas line.
- You prefer a heavier, more stable unit that resists tipping.
- You like the look and texture of cast concrete over metal.
Verdict: Choose the Ciays steel model if you value portability and propane flexibility. Pick the Elementi concrete model if you want a permanent, heavy-duty fixture with electronic ignition. Your decision depends on whether you prioritize ease of movement or permanent stability.
Steel And Concrete Fire Pit Comparison
Heat Output
The Ciays 42-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table delivers a substantial 60,000 BTU of heat. This high output helps keep you and your guests warm during chilly outdoor gatherings. The Elementi Manhattan model does not list a specific BTU rating in its published specifications. You must check the manufacturer's documentation for its heat output. Without that number, you cannot directly compare the thermal power of the two units. The Ciays specification provides a clear metric for heating capacity, while the Elementi data remains silent on this critical performance detail.
Fuel Type
Fuel availability often dictates convenience for outdoor heating. The Ciays model runs on propane, which offers portability since you can use standard tanks. The Elementi Manhattan uses natural gas, which typically requires a permanent line connection to your home. Natural gas provides unlimited fuel without refilling tanks, but propane allows for easier relocation if needed. Your choice depends on your patio setup. If you have a gas line, the Elementi is convenient. If you need flexibility, the Ciays propane option is more versatile for various outdoor locations.
Weight And Portability
Weight significantly impacts how you move and position these tables. The Ciays steel model weighs 65 pounds. This relatively light weight makes it easier for one person to adjust its location on a deck or patio. The Elementi cast concrete table weighs 173 pounds. This heavy weight suggests it is designed to stay in one fixed spot. Moving the Elementi unit would likely require multiple people or special equipment. If you plan to rearrange your outdoor furniture often, the lighter Ciays steel construction offers a practical advantage in terms of handling and placement flexibility.
Size And Space
Table dimensions affect how much space you need and how many people can gather. The Ciays table measures 42 inches in diameter and 43.3 inches in length. It offers a larger surface area for food and drinks. The Elementi model is a 36-inch square table. While still spacious, it is physically smaller than the Ciays option. The Ciays width is listed as 20 inches, likely referring to the base or internal component, but the overall footprint is larger. If you have a smaller patio or want a more compact centerpiece, the Elementi size may fit better. Otherwise, the Ciays provides more surface area.
Ignition And Controls
Starting the fire and adjusting the flame level changes your daily user experience. The Elementi Manhattan features electronic ignition, which likely simplifies starting the fire with a switch or button. The Ciays model includes an external fire level control for adjusting heat, but it does not specify an electronic ignition system. You may need to use a manual ignition method, such as a built-in spark generator or a separate lighter. The Elementi electronic feature offers a slight convenience edge for ease of use. However, both models allow you to control the flame intensity to suit your comfort needs during the evening.
Included Accessories
What comes in the box affects your initial setup and long-term maintenance. The Ciays package includes a steel lid and lava rocks. The lid protects the burner when not in use. The Elementi Manhattan includes a canvas cover and lava rocks. A canvas cover provides weather protection for the entire unit, which is beneficial for cast concrete. The Ciays steel lid only covers the opening. Both models include lava rocks for aesthetic appeal. The Elementi canvas cover offers broader protection against the elements compared to the Ciays steel lid, which is a practical difference for outdoor storage and maintenance.
Which fire pit suits your needs
You want high heat for gatherings
The Ciays model delivers 60,000 BTU of heat output. This high output keeps you and your guests warm during chilly evenings. It measures 42 inches wide, providing ample space for food and drinks. The steel lid and included lava rocks add to the atmosphere. You get strong warmth for outdoor parties.
You prefer natural gas convenience
The Elementi Manhattan uses natural gas fuel instead of propane. It features electronic ignition for easy starting. The cast concrete construction offers a distinct look. It includes a canvas cover for protection. This model connects directly to your home gas line, eliminating the need to refill tanks for each use.
You want a lighter portable table
The Ciays fire pit weighs 65 pounds. This is significantly lighter than the Elementi model, which weighs 173 pounds. The lighter weight makes it easier to move or rearrange on your patio. It has a steel lid for storage. You can adjust the heat level with an external control for comfort.
Quick picks
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ciays 42-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table | large patio gatherings needing high heat | Check price of Ciays 42-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table on Amazon |
| 2 | AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table | Permanent natural gas patio setups | Check price of AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table on Amazon |
The products compared
Ciays 42-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table
Best for: large patio gatherings needing high heat
- Material
- Steel (what this guide is about)
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Heat Output
- 60,000 BTU
- Diameter or Width
- 20 inches
- Included Accessories
- Steel lid, lava rocks
- Design
- Table
View on Amazon: Ciays 42-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table Affiliate link
This Ciays propane fire pit offers 60,000 BTU of heat output for outdoor gatherings. The 42-inch diameter provides ample surface area for food and drinks. It features a steel lid and includes lava rocks for visual appeal. The table measures 43.3 inches in length and weighs 65 pounds. It is designed for use on decks, gardens, or backyards. You get external fire level control for easy heat management.
Pros
- 60,000 BTU heat output
- 42-inch diameter table surface
- Includes steel lid and lava rocks
- External fire level control
Cons
- Steel lid may not match concrete material preference
- 65-pound weight limits portability
- Propane fuel requires tank management
Good fit if
- You want a steel fire pit with high heat output
- You need a large surface area for dining
- You prefer propane fuel for convenience
Skip if
- You prefer a concrete fire pit for durability
- You want a lightweight option for easy moving
- You need a gas fire pit with a glass cover
Verdict: Ciays 42-Inch Steel Gas Fire Pit is a solid choice for those who prioritize heat output and table space. It suits buyers who want a steel construction and easy propane access.
AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table
Best for: Permanent natural gas patio setups
- Material
- Concrete (what this guide is about)
- Fuel Type
- Natural Gas
- Diameter or Width
- 36 inches
- Ignition Type
- Electronic ignition
- Included Accessories
- Canvas cover, lava rock
- Design
- Table
View on Amazon: AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table Affiliate link
This square gas fire pit is built from cast concrete. It measures 36 by 36 inches with a 16-inch width. The unit weighs 173 pounds. It uses natural gas and features electronic ignition. You get a canvas cover and lava rocks included. This heavy table suits those wanting a permanent, solid outdoor feature.
Pros
- Cast concrete construction for durability
- Electronic ignition system
- Includes canvas cover and lava rocks
- Square 36-inch design
Cons
- Weighs 173 pounds
- Limited to natural gas fuel
- Heavy and bulky build
Good fit if
- You want a heavy, permanent table
- You have a natural gas line installed
- You prefer a square concrete design
Skip if
- You need propane flexibility
- You want a lightweight portable unit
- You prefer a round shape
Verdict: AMS Fireplace 36" Cast Concrete Fire Pit is a solid choice for those who want a heavy, permanent natural gas table. It suits patios where weight is not an issue and gas lines are available.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Ciays 42-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table | AMS Elementi Manhattan 36" Concrete Gas Fire Table |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel Type | Propane | Natural Gas |
| Heat Output | 60,000 BTU | not stated |
| Diameter or Width | 20 inches | 36 inches |
| Material | not stated | Cast concrete |
| Ignition Type | not stated | Electronic ignition |
| Included Accessories | Steel lid, lava rocks | Canvas cover, lava rock |
| Design | Table | Table |
| Features | Lava Rocks | Protective Cover, Lava Rocks |
| Use | Backyard, Garden, Deck | not stated |
| Color | Black | Manhattan - Dark Gray |
| Shape | not stated | Square |
| Dimensions | 43.3 × 20 × 24.4 inches | 36 × 16 × 36 inches |
| Weight | 65 pounds | 173 pounds |
| Size | 42 Inch with Lid | not stated |
| Model | CIFPT5B | not stated |
Frequently asked questions
Is steel or concrete better for a portable fire pit?
Steel is the better choice for portability. The Ciays steel model weighs 65 pounds, making it manageable to move. In contrast, the concrete Elementi table weighs 173 pounds. This significant weight makes the concrete option difficult to relocate once installed.
Do concrete fire pits hold heat longer than steel ones?
Concrete retains heat effectively due to its density. The Elementi concrete table provides steady warmth for gatherings. Steel heats up quickly but may cool faster. The Ciays steel unit offers high output but relies on active gas flow for sustained heat.
Which material looks more permanent on a patio?
Concrete offers a more permanent aesthetic. The Elementi table is designed for fixed natural gas hookups. Its heavy construction suggests a long-term installation. Steel tables like the Ciays model appear more versatile and less anchored to a specific spot.
Can I use a steel fire pit on a deck?
Yes, steel fire pits are suitable for decks. The Ciays steel unit is designed for use on decks, gardens, and backyards. Its lighter weight and table design make it adaptable. Ensure your deck can support the specific weight and heat requirements.
What is the difference in size between these two options?
The steel Ciays table measures 43.3 inches long and 42 inches wide. The concrete Elementi table is 36 inches square. The steel option provides a larger surface area. This extra space is useful for larger patio gatherings or placing more items.
Do I need a protective cover for these fire pits?
The Elementi concrete model comes with a protective cover included. This helps maintain the concrete finish. The Ciays steel model does not list a cover in its attributes. You may need to purchase a separate cover for the steel unit to protect it.
Is propane or natural gas better for these materials?
The choice depends on your fuel access. The steel Ciays model uses propane, offering flexibility without fixed lines. The concrete Elementi model uses natural gas, requiring a permanent connection. Propane allows easier relocation, while natural gas provides continuous fuel supply.