6 Best Alternatives to the Werph 17‑Inch Portable Propane Fire (2026)

Comparing key spec differences

Ciays 24-Inch Propane Fire Pit with Grill Grate

The Ciays 24-Inch model matches the 58,000 BTU heat output of the Werph but doubles the width to 24 inches. This larger footprint provides a wider flame spread and more surface area for cooking, thanks to the included grill grate. You gain significant versatility for group gatherings and meal preparation, but the trade-off is size and weight. At 37 pounds and 24 inches wide, it is much heavier and bulkier than the 17-pound, 17-inch Werph. If you need a stable cooking station for larger parties, this is the better choice. If you prioritize easy transport to a campsite or tight patio space, the compact Werph remains the superior option.

Outland Living 21-Inch Propane Fire Pit

The Outland Living 21-Inch unit offers the same 58,000 BTU heat rating but features a smokeless design and a 21-inch diameter. This is 4 inches wider than the Werph, providing a broader heat zone. It weighs 26 pounds, which is 9 pounds heavier than the Werph, making it less ideal for frequent moving. However, it includes a protective cover and is designed for tool-free setup, adding convenience. The smokeless feature reduces ash and debris, which the Werph does not explicitly advertise. Choose this if you want a dedicated outdoor heater with better smoke management. Pick the Werph if you need the lightest possible unit for camping trips where every pound matters.

Flame King 24-inch Smokeless Propane Fire Pit

The Flame King 24-Inch model provides 58,000 BTU of heat in a 24-inch frame, matching the smokeless design of some competitors. It is significantly larger and heavier than the Werph, weighing 27.3 pounds compared to the Werph’s 17 pounds. The key difference is the self-igniting feature, which removes the need for a separate lighter or match. This adds convenience for users who want instant flame control. However, you lose portability. The larger size and extra weight make it harder to carry to remote campsites. If you value easy ignition and a larger flame spread over lightweight portability, this model is a strong alternative. Otherwise, stick with the compact Werph.

Outland Living 24-Inch Propane Fire Pit

The Outland Living 24-Inch Round model delivers 58,000 BTU with a smokeless design and a 24-inch diameter. It is heavier at 34 pounds and wider than the 17-inch Werph. This unit includes a protective cover, offering better storage protection than the Werph’s integrated lid. The round shape and larger size create a more substantial gathering point for patios. You gain a complete kit for reliable, smokeless operation, but you sacrifice the lightweight, easy-carry nature of the Werph. This option suits users who leave the unit in one place. It is not ideal for frequent travel. If you need a sturdy, stationary heater with included accessories, this is a practical upgrade from the smaller Werph.

Outland Living 14-Inch Square Propane Fire Pit

The Outland Living 14-Inch Square Firecube is smaller than the Werph, with a 14-inch width versus the Werph’s 17 inches. It weighs 22.5 pounds, which is 5.5 pounds heavier despite the smaller footprint. This square design offers a unique aesthetic for small patios or camping spots. It includes lava rocks, which provide a different flame texture compared to the Werph’s pumice stones. The smokeless design ensures clean burning. You get a distinct shape and included rocks, but you pay extra for weight and lose the wider heat spread of the Werph. This is best for users who want a compact, square heater with included rocks. Choose the Werph for a wider, lighter, and more traditional round fire pit.

Outland Living 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit

The Outland Living 19-Inch Portable model offers 58,000 BTU of heat in a 19-inch frame. It is slightly larger and heavier than the Werph, weighing 22 pounds compared to 17 pounds. The smokeless design is a key advantage, reducing ash and improving air quality around the flame. This makes it suitable for decks and patios where smoke is a concern. The 2-inch width increase provides a bit more heat coverage. However, the extra weight and size make it less portable than the Werph. If you prioritize smokeless operation and a bit more warmth in a portable package, this is a solid choice. If you need the absolute lightest option for backpacking or tight spaces, the 17-inch Werph remains the better fit.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Werph 17-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit

Best for: camping and small patios

Fuel Type

Propane

Heat Output

58,000 BTU

Diameter or Width

17 inches

Included Accessories

2-in-1 lid, pumice stones

Use

Backyard, Camping, RV

Color

Black

View on Amazon: Werph 17-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit Affiliate link

This 17-inch propane fire pit delivers 58,000 BTU of heat in a compact, lightweight design. The stainless steel burner and one-piece construction offer durability, while the 2-in-1 locking lid protects the unit and stabilizes it. Weighing just 17 pounds, it is easy to carry for camping or patio use. The adjustable flame control lets you tailor the warmth, and the included pumice stones help spread heat evenly.

Pros

• 58,000 BTU heat output from a stainless steel burner
• Lightweight 17-pound build for easy transport
• 2-in-1 locking lid acts as a protective cover and stable base
• Compact 17-inch diameter fits small spaces
• Adjustable flame control knob for precise heat management

Cons

• 17-inch diameter is smaller than the 19- to 24-inch options on this list
• 17-pound weight is slightly heavier than the 16.5-pound claim suggests
• No grill grate included for cooking

Good fit if

• You need a fire pit that fits easily in a car for camping trips
• You want a compact unit for a small patio or balcony
• You prefer a sleek, one-piece design without visible welds

Skip if

• You want a large fire pit for a big backyard gathering
• You need to cook food on a grill grate
• You prefer a lighter unit under 16 pounds

Verdict: Werph 17-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit is a practical choice for campers and those with limited outdoor space. Its compact size and sturdy lid make it ideal for portable warmth rather than large-scale entertaining.

2 Also great

Ciays 24-Inch Propane Fire Pit with Grill Grate

Best for: cooking and large group gatherings

Fuel Type

Propane

Heat Output

58,000 BTU

Diameter or Width

24 inches

Ignition Type

Piezo Electric Ignition

Included Accessories

Grate, 10 ft hose, lava rock, lid

Features

Protective Cover, Cooking Grate

View on Amazon: Ciays 24-Inch Propane Fire Pit with Grill Grate Affiliate link

This Ciays unit offers 58,000 BTU of heat output in a 24-inch diameter design. It includes a cast iron grate for cooking, piezo electric ignition, and a flameout protection system. The foldable legs and included carrying strap make it portable. It is a solid option for those who want a larger fire bowl that also serves as a cooking surface.

Pros

• 24-inch diameter provides ample heat coverage
• Includes a durable cast iron cooking grate
• Piezo electric ignition requires no batteries
• Flameout protection shuts off fuel if flames extinguish
• Foldable legs and carrying strap aid transport

Cons

• Heavier at 37 pounds compared to lighter competitors
• Lacks a remote control or smartphone app for operation
• Standard piezo ignition may be less convenient than electronic push-button starts

Good fit if

• You want a fire pit large enough for group gatherings
• You need a cooking grate for outdoor meals
• You prefer battery-free ignition reliability

Skip if

• You prioritize lightweight portability under 30 pounds
• You want remote control or smart app functionality
• You prefer a smaller footprint for tight spaces

Verdict: Ciays 24-Inch Propane Fire Pit with Grill suits buyers who need a large, stable heating source that doubles as a cooking station. It is ideal for campers and patio users who value cooking versatility over remote convenience.

3 Also great

Outland Living 21-Inch Propane Fire Pit

Best for: camping, RV trips, and small patios

Fuel Type

Propane

Heat Output

58,000 BTU

Diameter or Width

21 inches

Material

Steel

Included Accessories

Cover, carry kit, hose, lava rocks

Design

Smokeless

View on Amazon: Outland Living 21-Inch Propane Fire Pit Affiliate link

This portable propane fire pit features a 21-inch diameter bowl and 58,000 BTU heat output. It weighs 26 pounds and stands 9.25 inches tall. The unit includes a protective cover, carry kit, and 10-foot hose. You get a smokeless flame with natural lava rocks. It is CSA approved for use during campfire bans. This model suits those needing a compact, tool-free setup for patios or camping.

Pros

• 58,000 BTU heat output
• 21-inch diameter steel bowl
• Includes protective cover and carry kit
• No assembly required
• CSA approved for safety

Cons

• 26 pounds is heavier than some competitors
• Propane tank not included
• Hose length limits tank placement distance

Good fit if

• You need a smokeless flame for camping or RV trips
• You want a unit that requires no assembly
• You prefer a compact 21-inch diameter for small spaces

Skip if

• You require a larger 24-inch or bigger fire bowl
• You need a fire pit table with integrated seating
• You want a unit lighter than 26 pounds

Verdict: Outland Living 21-Inch Propane Fire Pit offers a compact, tool-free setup with included carrying gear. It fits buyers who prioritize portability and safety certifications for outdoor gatherings.

4 Also great

Flame King 24-inch Smokeless Propane Fire Pit

Best for: Users wanting a larger 24-inch flame spread

Fuel Type

Propane

Heat Output

58,000 BTU/HR

Diameter or Width

24 inches

Ignition Type

Self-igniting (auto ignition), piezo

Included Accessories

Hose with regulator, lava rocks, cover

Design

Smokeless

View on Amazon: Flame King 24-inch Smokeless Propane Fire Pit Affiliate link

This Flame King unit features a 24-inch diameter bowl and 58,000 BTU heat output. It uses a self-igniting piezo system for easy startup. The package includes lava rocks, a protective cover, and a carry strap. It connects to standard propane tanks via a 10-foot hose. This setup suits those wanting a larger flame spread and hassle-free lighting for outdoor gatherings.

Pros

• 24-inch diameter provides a wide flame spread
• 58,000 BTU heat output for strong warmth
• Self-igniting piezo system eliminates matches
• Includes lava rocks for enhanced flame appearance
• Comes with a protective cover and carry strap

Cons

• 27.3 pounds weight is heavier than smaller models
• 10-foot hose limits placement distance from tank
• No remote control for flame adjustment

Good fit if

• You want a larger 24-inch fire bowl for bigger groups
• You prefer self-igniting ignition for convenience
• You need a complete package with a cover and carry strap

Skip if

• You need a portable unit under 20 pounds
• You require a remote control for operation
• You prefer a smaller 17-inch or 19-inch footprint

Verdict: Flame King 24-Inch Smokeless Propane Fire Pit offers a larger burning area and self-igniting convenience for users prioritizing flame size and ease of use over portability.

5 Best premium

Outland Living 24-Inch Propane Fire Pit

Best for: Smokeless round fire pits with included cover

Fuel Type

Propane

Heat Output

58,000 BTU/hr

Diameter or Width

24 inches

Material

Steel, stainless steel

Included Accessories

10-ft hose, regulator, lava rocks, cover

Design

Smokeless

View on Amazon: Outland Living 24-Inch Propane Fire Pit Affiliate link

This Outland Living model delivers 58,000 BTU/hr of heat from a 24-inch round steel bowl. It features a smokeless design and comes with a 10-ft hose, regulator, lava rocks, and a UV-resistant cover. The unit weighs 34 pounds and requires no assembly. It suits those who want a clean, realistic flame without the mess of wood, ideal for patios or camping trips where fire bans apply.

Pros

• 58,000 BTU/hr heat output
• 24-inch round smokeless design
• Includes 10-ft hose and lava rocks
• No assembly required
• Comes with protective UV cover

Cons

• Manual ignition only
• Heavier at 34 pounds
• Propane tank not included

Good fit if

• You need a smokeless flame for campfire bans
• You want a ready-to-use kit with cover
• You prefer a round fire bowl design

Skip if

• You require remote control or app connectivity
• You need a square fire pit shape
• You want a lighter unit under 20 pounds

Verdict: Outland Living 24-Inch Round Smokeless Propane Fire Pit offers reliable heat and a complete kit for users who prioritize convenience and smokeless operation over advanced features like remote ignition.

6 Best lava rocks

Outland Living 14-Inch Square Propane Fire Pit

Best for: small patios and camping trips

Fuel Type

Propane

Heat Output

58,000 BTU/HR

Diameter or Width

14 in

Material

Steel, stainless steel burner

Design

Smokeless

Features

Protective Cover, Lava Rocks

View on Amazon: Outland Living 14-Inch Square Propane Fire Pit Affiliate link

The Outland Living Firecube is a compact, square propane fire pit designed for small spaces. It delivers 58,000 BTU of heat output in a 14-inch footprint. The unit weighs 22.5 pounds, making it highly portable for camping or RV trips. It includes a set of natural lava rocks to enhance the flame effect. This smokeless design allows use during most campfire bans.

Pros

• Compact 14-inch square design fits small patios
• Lightweight 22.5-pound build for easy transport
• Includes 4.4-pound natural lava rocks
• 58,000 BTU heat output for warmth

Cons

• 14-inch width is smaller than most competitors
• Square shape offers less seating space
• No remote control for flame adjustment

Good fit if

• You need a fire pit for a small balcony
• You want a lightweight option for camping
• You prefer a square fire pit design

Skip if

• You require a remote control for operation
• You need a large fire pit for big groups
• You prefer a round fire bowl shape

Verdict: Outland Living 14-Inch Square Firecube suits campers and those with limited patio space who prioritize portability over large seating capacity.

7 Best budget

Outland Living 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit

Best for: compact camping and tailgating setups

Fuel Type

Propane

Heat Output

58,000 BTU/hr

Diameter or Width

19 inches

Material

Steel, stainless steel

Included Accessories

10-ft hose, regulator, lava rock set

Design

Smokeless

View on Amazon: Outland Living 19-Inch Portable Propane Fire Pit Affiliate link

The Outland Living 19-inch propane fire pit delivers 58,000 BTU of heat in a compact 19 by 19 by 11-inch frame. It weighs 22 pounds and uses a steel bowl with a stainless steel burner. The kit includes a 10-foot hose, regulator, and lava rocks. You get a smokeless flame that requires no assembly. This model fits well for tailgating or small patios where space is tight.

Pros

• 58,000 BTU/hr heat output
• Compact 19-inch diameter design
• Includes 10-ft hose and lava rocks
• No assembly required

Cons

• Smaller 19-inch bowl compared to 21- or 24-inch alternatives
• Heavier 22-pound build limits easy carrying
• Propane tank not included

Good fit if

• You need a compact fire pit for tailgating or camping
• You want a smokeless flame without ash cleanup
• You prefer a unit that requires no assembly

Skip if

• You want a larger 24-inch fire bowl for more heat spread
• You need a fire pit table with seating
• You prefer a lighter unit for frequent carrying

Verdict: Outland Living 19-inch Propane Fire Pit offers reliable heat in a portable package, making it a solid choice for campers and tailgaters who prioritize compact size over maximum warmth.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions

See also

• hp 17 inch fhd laptop alternatives
• jibufi 17 inches space heaters alternatives